I've been here a long time too, and honestly, this tracks with what I've watched happen. It's got a lot more visible in the several years. More so around Covid, everything shifted so fast that a lot of normal checks got dropped, and some people never brought them back once things settled. It just took a while for the effects to show up in the open. Now it feels obvious. It seems like people who couldn't tell you their own KPIs if you asked them point blank keep moving up. People who've never built a real relationship with anyone on their team get handed bigger ones. Meanwhile the leaders who actually knew the work, who pushed for something better than the bare minimum, get labeled disruptive and slowly pushed out.
That part is frustrating on its own. But the thing that's harder to say is how accountability feels like it's changed. From what I've seen and heard, concerns raised through the right channels don't seem to go anywhere. Whether that's the outcome of a fair process or something else, I can't say for certain, but the perception among a lot of people is that it stops looking like coincidence after a while. And once people believe that, they stop reporting, and leadership can end up reading the silence as proof everything's fine.
It feels like HR used to function as more of a check on this stuff than it does now. A lot of hiring seems to come down to relationships and loyalty, not just ability. You see VPs with a full team underneath them, admin support, everything they could ask for, and it still doesn't translate to results, while the people actually keeping things running are stretched thin without any of that support. I don't think we've fully sat with how far this has slipped.
What gets me is that there are good leaders here. I've seen younger managers who genuinely care, who coach people, who want to build something. And it feels like they keep getting overtaken by people who show little interest in any of that and treat leadership as their next promotion. Leading people shouldn't be a reward for playing the game well upward. It should come with responsibility to the people below you and to the place you work. It feels like we stopped expecting either a while ago, and it shows. If this company wants to be what it used to be, that's the thing that actually has to change.