Thread regarding Verizon Communications Inc. layoffs

Fake Green Card Job Interviews are Really Stupid. Read on to get the Truth! Ignore to Remain Ignorant!

These fake interviews that are being discussed here apply to the Green Card process. The issue is with the stupid immigration system. This is how it works. A candidate applies for a Job at Verizon and to get the job, he/she competes with all other candidates. The candidate is selected based on his skills and performance in the interview and he joins the company as a full-time employee through H1B visa which the company sponsors. Once US Govt acknowledges the receipt of H1B (about 2 weeks), the candidate starts working. Let's say, he has worked for 6 months and he asks his manager to initiate Green Card based on his current job for which he interviewed and currently performing. The manager seeks VP approval and the Green card process is initiated. This is where the stupidity comes in. The Green card is for his/her current job for which he/she already went thru the interview process and got selected. Why would you subject that candidate to another interview for the same job? The stupidity of immigration law demands that a Job description is posted, candidates are interviewed, etc. In this situation, you can't possibly select others. Doing so will force that candidate to move out of the company. Hence, the interview is not just fake but downright stupid. For any US company to sponsor H1B, that candidate EITHER needs to be working in the US on an H1B visa through another company OR the candidate is working in that company's foreign office.

There is another situation where the interview for Green card job makes sense. This is when you have a position and no candidate is already working for that position. Manager will conduct the interview, select a candidate, and initiate the Green card process without going through H1B. The candidate can start working ONLY after he/she gets the Green card. This is so stupid at multiple levels. First, if you desperately need an Einstein, you can't wait until Einstein gets his Green Card through this process. Einstein may not have a backlog as a german Citizen but Pitchai or Nadella (from India) would have a lot more waiting time. Secondly, a manager has not seen this candidate's work ethic/skills in action and he is already spending a good amount of money just based on interview. No American company does this unless an Uncle owns the company and has a Green card Job and his nephew is the beneficiary.

Hope this helps.

Disclaimer: Originally from India, I joined Verizon through H1B visa and my boss liked my work ethic/skills and started my Green card process which got approved after 10 years. Applied for US citizenship, 5 years after Green card approval. Took the VSP package recently. Life as an H1B is interesting and it is not easily relatable to native-born US citizens although they may do the same job every day. Even my US-born kids would never understand what I went through. They dismiss that as one of the dad jokes! 😜

by
| 3797 views | | 21 replies (last August 12, 2019) | Reply
Post ID: @OP+10nAepw2

21 replies (most recent on top)

Easy. Send it all to India, the company will make more money and important jobs such as Engineering will stay!

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @8ubg+10nAepw2

As prosperity is increasing in India even Indians have started to understand the flavors of H1B Slavery. In the past conditions in India were so dire that many people thought $60k H1B slavery for 10 - 15 years was worth more than being left behind in India but that has changed now.

As a matter of fact a economic class of 1990s are no longer dreaming to come to USA for $60K a year. We are getting the new dirt poor economic class who is still willing to slave themselves for $60k a year/80 hours a week.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @4bqn+10nAepw2

Exactly. That's been going on since at least the mid 90s.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @3vyf+10nAepw2

Another way, this "really works" (at least in the past). At some point American companies weren't allowed to hire H1B if qualified Americans were available. If they had no qualified American candidates they could hire an H1B worker.

When my brother, who is a software engineer, would apply for a job, they would have impossible requirements. For example – they would require five years experience on software that had only been in existence for a year. Obviously no one could meet the requirements of the job, under those circumstances.

So when American workers "didn't qualify", they could interview H1B candidates, who weren't required to qualify.

The big corporations pulled this scam over and over again.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @3gpb+10nAepw2

@10nAepw2-2exu Unfortunately the companies and many politicians support this. Its up to us to oppose them

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2qno+10nAepw2

@10nAepw2-2xfa - Dont let stupids lead you to the wrong definition of capitalism. You can lose your job to anyone within the boundry of a Nation, thats just competition but if the rich and powerful immigrate people for the sole intention of bringing down the wages for natives you need to call that out.

Yes..IBM and Verizon can operate their business from India and hire all the Indians they want there. But in USA they need to hire Americans.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2exu+10nAepw2

If your job can adequately be done by a 60K/yr immigrant, then I guess it doesn't make sense for the company to pay you 150K to do the same thing. So it drives down wages towards an equilibrium. If you want to be paid more than twice what a dude from India would get, then I guess you better get to work proving you're worth it. It's the circle of life, dude. My dad lost his job in the 70s when the industry he was in moved south to hire people who would work for peanuts. The Carolinas lost those jobs later to the Far East for the same reason, and now they are losing to Vietnam, Thailand, and Indonesia. You want to make the big bucks, then roll with the changes and find some way to show you are better.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2xfa+10nAepw2

@10nAepw2-2mwc

Correct more corruption from SA and VG

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2aej+10nAepw2

I am not blaming the capitalist immigrants on this. I am blaming the capitalist corporatists, the capitalist politicians, lazy and unproductive managers who are dependent of slave labor, and the industry around it.

A poor immigrant is taking on 15 - 20 years of slavery for the sake of his family. How can we be racist against the poor immigrant. This poor immigrant is immigrating in the states in the same scenarios as how all the poor/starving/sick Europeans migrated to USA with hopes of better lives for their family.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2gcf+10nAepw2

Verizon Wireless stopped doing new visa sponsorship about 13 years ago because it wasn't needed. It suddenly became necessary to have visa sponsorship in wireless again when Verizon took over. Wireless takeover was a great expansion of the hiring friends and family or getting kickbacks program for Verizon IT managers.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2mwc+10nAepw2

ALL publicly traded companies abuse the system. This is not isolated to Verizon.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1qsm+10nAepw2

The visa process and abuse in IT is about a lack of leadership. Mgrs and directors want like people ( look at SA and VG) and hire sponsored employees for entry level and common skill jobs. I worked for three VPs and only one pushed back on the abuse and he was let go. It’s about leadership and the current IT leadership abuses the system

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1qog+10nAepw2

You are correct sir. Just look at SA and VG. How a one time temp IT work on H1B visa became executives in the same company 20 years later. That is what the H1B candidates are looking for their hard work of 80 hrs a week and minimum salary of $60k. They are betting on the future like SA and VG. H1Bs like SA and VG won, companies like VZ won with cheap labor, American consumers won too in a way for cheaper products and services, but displaced American IT workers lost.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1akr+10nAepw2

I dare Bezos and Kochs and their cronie political partners to offer foreigners a straight up green card if we need more IT help.

I am open for bringing in foreigners as we need it because we want to remain as a " number one" market for innovations. We want to outrace any other country in technology and if we need to hoard talent or just workers for that reason i am all for it. But lets give them a standard work permit for 6 years. Let them compete with Americans and let them have freedom to move in and out of the companies with their choice for that given period of work permit. Let them go in and out of country for that given period of time. Lets not tie them with any crazy visa slavery rules. Will the corporate America do that? absolutely not because the goal of H1B visa is not to fill the unfilled tech position, it is to drive down the IT wages. If you bring foreign workers with freedom to switch the companies and freedom to move around they will compete for $150K jobs. The market will be for $150K average and not $60K average. Also the slave mongering managers will not be able to work someone 80 hrs a week for $60K salary.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1csj+10nAepw2

@10nAepw2-1nyk Very well put.

The only thing i would add is. Because of the other 3 points, a slew of companies have sprung up supplying these H1 contractors to hiring companies. These consulting companies (not all) have started multiple corrupt practices - False resume (they frequently add years of fake experience), bribing hiring managers, taking a huge cut from the hourly rate etc

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1hlt+10nAepw2

@10nAepw2 - Here is the scam in this whole H1B deal.

Firstly a Macro scam - The Gates, Kochs, Bezos, wanting to keep the IT wages as cheap as possible so that they can keep on becoming more and more successful capitalists. More they bring from outside lower the IT wage goes. They will partner/finance their corrupt politicians mostly Republicans and some Democrats too to make this happen legally and politically.

Second Scam: The H1B jobs were marketed and sold to Americans as a temporary position that could not be filled at a "moment". This was not supposed to be a path to green card or the citizenship but since with the help of our capitalist players and corrupt politicians the "moment" could be defined for any numbers of years now. There was a reason why H1B were given for 3 years first and another 3 if needed...then the lawyers and our famous politicians opened further extension to it and now its almost like one can spend his whole career on work visa. The pay in H1B visa is so low that most foreign workers would not want to come live in the USA for that $60K salary. for eg quality of life with $20k in India is far more better than the quality of life with $60K in USA. But yet many foreigners will come sacrifice the 15 years of their lives here in the hopes of better lives for their kids. Thats the investment they are doing. What that investment does to USA is that now the IT Wages will stick around $60 forever. They can easlity tell an American that if you do not want $75k for this $150K job i have an indian wanting to work for $60K. The immigrant already knows what he is investing in. He does not care much about the low wages now. He is thinking about hat $150k he is going to make after 15 years and the future of his kids.

The third scam: Those are the American Hiring managers mostly whites, those lazy bunch has become so addicted to cheap labor, the yes sirs, and pleasing their own bosses by reducing the cost in their department that they simply do not care about anything else. Those fraudsters will get a cheap labor that works for $60k year 80 hours a week and sleeps at home easy. He gets his bonus and he loves his " hard working foreigners". Almost like the juice of slavery that has missed couple generations in his family is back to his generation in the form of H1Bs.

The bottom line is that the H1B were supposed to be temporary and every foreign worker should accept the job thinking its a temp position and then look to go back.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1nyk+10nAepw2

H1Bs cost US citizens jobs and lower the US standard of living. Furthermore, the incoming H1Bs are not very talented as the H1B resource pool has been drained.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1jwr+10nAepw2

The H1b visa process should be ended. There are plenty of Americans that need jobs.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1zmy+10nAepw2

The immigration laws of the USA need to be changed if you do not want to attract immigrants. As long as there is a legal process, you would see legal immigrants in your workplace. Work with your Congressman/woman, Senators and the President to completely shut down legal immigration.
I personally would vote for a candidate who supports a merit-based legal immigration system since I believe in America the melting pot. I understand a lot of folks would have lost the sense of where they originally came from. Love and hugs to Native Indians for welcoming immigrants to their shores!

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @osn+10nAepw2

Try hiring an American for a change.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @qhf+10nAepw2

Trust me - Pitchai or Nadella are no Einsteins and I really have no sympathy for them as long as more qualified American citizens are being displaced by them.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @drn+10nAepw2

Post a reply

: