Thread regarding Humana Inc. layoffs

CMS Star Ratings

Everyone on LinkedIn is praising and congratulating Humana on getting higher CMS Star Ratings and as a result a big bump in stock price after the market closed today.

Well, of course they did. They did so by exiting all their lower star rated plans from prior year, leaving 600k members in the lurch, to have to quickly find a new plan. Elderly people have enough stress as there is.

I don’t praise Humana for this. Watch, now we will have some of the slickest actors in fancy commercials telling these members how they can sign with a new Humana plan. If I was one of those members I would go with someone else besides Humana to give them a message that I was not pleased for terminating my current plan.


by
| 254 views | | 15 replies (last October 12) | Reply
Post ID: @OP+1m4fatdfm

15 replies (most recent on top)

@tf Wow, so clever. Congratulations. Your Mom would be so proud. :)

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @ts+1m4fatdfm

The b-ms will always lose! Do you hear me Lebowski? The b-ms will ALWAYS lose!

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @tf+1m4fatdfm

@nb Let’s face it; they won. Somehow the large corporations, no matter their underlying practices, always do. Same goes for the ultra rich.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @sj+1m4fatdfm

I suspect some smoke and mirrors provided this illusion of success.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @nb+1m4fatdfm

@cs Actually, I am not saying that.

But the reason I am replying is I wanted to thank you so much for your expression of appreciation for me having shared my post.

That was very kind of you and much appreciated! It was my pleasure. Thanks for reading and have a wonderful day!

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @dx+1m4fatdfm

@cc so you are telling us you don’t know how star ratings are calculated? Thanks for sharing, I guess

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @cs+1m4fatdfm

If anyone happens to come across my post on LinkedIn regarding this subject matter, please feel free to repost it. I would not object to having 100k reposts. Not because I care about any stats; could care less. But because I think the news media has failed us in telling the whole transparent truth on things. So, up to us now.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @cd+1m4fatdfm

@c8 I stand by my comments. Had Humana not exited those plans, they would not have had an overall higher star ratings average and their stock would not have soared today.

And by your using firstly and secondly, obviously you read my post on LinkedIn.

Not sure if that is intended to intimidate me but it does not.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @cc+1m4fatdfm

Firstly, exiting plans hurts star ratings. Secondly, the star ratings released yesterday are based on 2025 performance, so the 2027 plan exits have no bearing on the scores.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @c8+1m4fatdfm

@bq Healthcare and health insurance never should have turned into a profit making venture. I know this flies in the face to all you finance and accounting majors.

But healthcare and the insurance that is supposed to cover such is by definition intended to be what some might term a “bleeding heart” mission of caring. And particularly for our elderly, disabled, and indigent.

This should not be about the numbers. In fact, Medicare and Medicaid and the companies that administrate those should be willing to take a loss, if it means covering the healthcare expenses for those in need. And terminating their plans, just because they were to expensive and not profitable ends up placing the burden on those members.

That is why Medicare administration really needs to either be completely handed back over to traditional medicare or else the government should be contracting with non-profit companies.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @br+1m4fatdfm

Didn’t they drop some plans this year? And aren’t the scores from last year?

Strategic planning requires impactful decisions to be made.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @bq+1m4fatdfm

It is so shameful I am tempted to call it out, the way Humana did this, on LinkedIn.

At this point, I really no longer care about keeping my identity anonymous. This corporation has really took a big time turn for the worse and only increasingly getting even more so.

And they are going to continue profiting while continuing to cause human suffering is beyond contemptible.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @bn+1m4fatdfm

Humana has nothing to cheer about here! Not worthy of a pat on the back or a fist pump. All you did was artificially raise your star rating average by removing the bottom numbers on the bell curve. I think they call that cheating actually.

And who paid for that? Yep, the poor members whose policies you terminated.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @bk+1m4fatdfm

Humana Executives chose to raise their stock at the expense (on the backs) of 600,000 members who they terminated their coverage so that Humana could raise their overall star ratings because those members were bringing them down. Shameful!

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @bg+1m4fatdfm

Maybe my favorite NFL team can pull a Humana and simply drop their five worst games for the year so they can get into the Super Bowl.

Or maybe my favorite PGA golfer could simply drop several of scores in his worst holes so he can win the tournament.

Or maybe when someone goes to get their annual physical, they could just have the doctor subtract 15 Lbs. from their weight and ten points from their systolic pressure.

I mean, that is how we do things now, I take it. We don’t try to fix things, we just quit or exit them.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @a5+1m4fatdfm

Post a reply

: