This is reality regardless of what the disenchanted and haters stay.These are just the facts.
Bottom line: Under the leadership team in place since mid-2024, Mutual of America has made measurable progress—dramatically smaller losses, meaningful cost cuts, stable capital, and constructive rating-agency outlooks. It is on a recovery path and management is targeting sustained profitability in 2026. Success is not yet locked in, but the trajectory is positive and the worst of the capital erosion and large losses appears to be behind it.
SEE BELOW FOR DETAILS:
Mutual of America is showing clear signs of recovery, though it is not yet fully restored to consistent profitability.Key evidence of progress (through 2025 / early 2026)Sharply reduced operating losses: Operating losses fell from roughly $223 million in 2023 → ~$150 million in 2024 → $27.6 million in 2025. This is a major improvement driven by aggressive cost actions.
spglobal.com
Cost reductions: In 2025 the company cut operating expenses by about $90 million (roughly 25%) through a smaller real-estate footprint, workforce optimization, and lower third-party spending.
spglobal.com
Positive (though thin) net income: Statutory net income was positive at ~$2.4 million in 2025 (vs. large losses in prior years). Much of the positivity still came from one-time investment/real-estate gains, similar to the 2024 building-sale boost.
streetinsider.com
Balance-sheet and operating metrics: Total assets under administration rose to $27.9 billion. Client retention remained solid (assets ~91%). Management reports “significant progress,” “positive momentum,” and a clear path toward profitability, with a stated goal of reaching it in 2026.
mutualofamerica.com
Rating agency outlooks stabilized: Fitch affirmed BBB+ and revised the outlook to Stable (from Negative) in June 2026.
fitchratings.com
S&P lowered the rating to A- in April 2026 but assigned a Stable outlook, citing the turnaround plan focused on revenue growth and expense reduction.
spglobal.com
AM Best rates it A- (as of April 2026).
mutualofamerica.com
Remaining challenges Core operations are still loss-making (though the losses are now much smaller).
Statutory surplus edged down slightly in 2025 (to ~$549 million from ~$577 million at year-end 2024). The broader “Total Surplus” figure highlighted by the company was $651 million (vs. $715 million the prior year).
mutualofamerica.com
Business remains concentrated in nonprofit/group retirement products, with ongoing execution risk on the turnaround and potential for further regulatory reserve pressure.
Ratings are lower than historical peaks (they were higher a few years ago).