AS of current price today 10/13 BNY is down $10.43 per share or 6.9% over past 3 months (7/13 to 10/13). same period of time JPM up $00.69. I don't think the negative trend is sector related.
15 replies (most recent on top)
They’ll go back up after they do the next round of layoffs after Thanksgiving. Just like last year. The week they do EoY reviews, they’ll cut another 5% of workforce and the stock will jump back up
@fw
You were the one saying garbage first and then you started shoveling it here. You know what? You should take all the money you have and buy BNY stock with it. That’s right. Take every cent you have and go BNY all the way because you can cherry pick points in time. By your bizarro logic, even if BNY declines to $120 we are still up YTD. Just remember, it only matters when you sell it genius. Why then, dont you buy 40,000 shares of BNY? Then you can live comfortably outside Pittsburgh off the dividend income yield. LOL.. Go on … do it. Meanwhile nothing you splattered here is the point of this thead or what the analysts are reporting on for BNY’s outlook.
@f4 In case you cannot read the "garbage" it contains the 3 month data posted also stating that BNY gave up 4.1 to STT 2.8 percent. Whereas JPM gained 1.9% and that too because like MS they have a equity desk.
Let's keep it going, why this board is full of falsehood - You're welcome to hate the and be in denial about the returns. BNY as an individual stock beat S&P hands down - over the last 5 years. You are welcome to extend it to ten years and check it out
Downvoting and name calling the data / truth is not going to change the fact that most of the ESPP investors have a significant gain and are happy
The 10000$ invested has grown to 30,000 - a solid return compared to S&P 500. Chat GPT is not a BNY employee
Chat GPT provided data
Here is a prompt that you can use with ChatGPT
Provide a quick performance audit comparing BNY with STT, NTRS, and JPM over four timeframes: YTD, 1-Year, 3-Year, and 5-Year.
Include:
A table showing Percentage Return & ROI.
A table showing the dollar value of $10,000 invested at each interval (1-Yr, 3-Yr, 5-Yr).
Specify whether figures represent stock price appreciation alone or total shareholder return (with reinvested dividends)."
| Timeframe | BNY | STT | NTRS | JPM |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| YTD 2026 | +24.47% | +52.66% | +37.25% | +4.84% |
| 1-Year | +35.80% | +75.65% | +46.34% | +9.69% |
| 3-Year | +266.17% | +197.91% | +160.87% | +138.65% |
| 5-Year | +199.78% | +156.60% | +86.93% | +133.05% |
Investment value = $10,000 × (1 + cumulative total return)
| Stock | After 1 Year | After 3 Years | After 5 Years |
| -------- | -----------: | ------------: | ------------: |
| BNY | $13,580 | $36,617 | $29,978 |
| STT | $17,565 | $29,791 | $25,660 |
| NTRS | $14,634 | $26,087 | $18,693 |
| JPM | $10,969 | $23,865 | $23,305 |
Similar prompt to gemini - in case someone believes that chatGPT is BNY stooge
ROI - Growth of 10,000 investment and dividend reinvestment
Bank / Benchmark 1-Year Value 3-Year Value 5-Year Value 5-Year Net Profit ($)
BNY Mellon (BNY) $15,915 $32,242 $28,299 +$18,299
State Street (STT) $15,608 $29,636 $22,211 +$12,211
Northern Trust (NTRS) $13,214 $18,830 $16,849 +$6,849
JPMorgan Chase (JPM) $11,109 $24,512 $22,622 +$12,622
S&P 500 (SPX) $11,574 $12,289 $11,379 +$1,379
Percentage Total Returns & ROI Summary
Bank / BenchmarkTicker YTD 1-Year 3-Year 5-Year
BNY Mellon BNY +23.40% +59.15% +222.42% +182.99%
State StreetSTT +38.15% +56.08% +196.36% +122.11%
Northern TrustNTRS +25.00% +32.14% +88.30% +68.49%
JPMorgan ChaseJPM +5.33% +11.09% +145.12% +126.22%
S&P 500 IndexSPX +12.75% +15.74% +22.89% +13.79%
@e7
You know what is garbage? People like you who come here with cherry picked stats and false narratives. The so called stats belched out here conveniently left out performance from end of the second quarter onward. And you are probably the sole source of this cr.ap because you want to be right and aren’t. This stock is overinflated. And its been said many times here about revenue and earnings are a big concern with it. If you want to be a cinder block head, then do it on your own time and stay away from here. Oh and BNY is down another 3.5% on price metrics today. Its been heading downward for a while. That’s the point Winky. Not YTD.
BNY drops to $135. The earnings call with RV and DM is bound to be dramatic — get your popcorn ready!
Short term trends vary. Look at YoY return or YTD. Charlie had an earnings beat at WFC but they're down because of revenue miss. And is up JPM and missed earnings but had revenue growth and delayed deals that dragged down Q3 earnings but will show up Q4.
Sad state of affairs and this board have become garbage. It used to provide layoff rumors and information. Now it has become a place to vent and post speculative lies - One item like 5 days RTO in March 26.
Back to stock price - the data posted @bn just proves @at 's assertion. And data does not lie like an individual. And it can be verified with ChatGPT like tools. Just ask the query is free of charge.
YTD - BNY has returned 20% price appreciation WITH the decline in the last 3 months.
That is data, public data.
@bn
Uhhh thanks for the nonsense ‘Eliza’
Here is a Gemini produced report - YTD and last quarter - and BNY which had a higher return did give up and consolidated.
No bias here - I do not enjoy BNY but have holdings through ESPP and will be worried otherwise
TICKER | COMPANY NAME | PRICE ($) | MKT CAP ($B) | P/E (TTM) | YTD RET | PRIMARY SERVICE
-------+----------------------------+-----------+--------------+-----------+---------+----------------------------------
BNY | Bank of New York Mellon | 141.03 | 103.4 | 17.0x | +20.5% | Custody, Asset Servicing & Mgmt
STT | State Street Corp | 112.50 | 34.2 | 14.8x | +18.2% | Custody, Asset Servicing & ETFs
GS | Goldman Sachs Group | 895.32 | 260.7 | 13.6x | +16.8% | Investment Banking & Trading
MS | Morgan Stanley | 190.31 | 298.4 | 15.2x | +15.4% | Wealth Management & IB
JPM | JPMorgan Chase & Co. | 332.99 | 885.2 | 14.2x | +14.1% | Universal Banking & Commercial
WFC | Wells Fargo & Company | 74.80 | 252.7 | 12.0x | +11.6% | Consumer & Commercial Banking
C | Citigroup Inc. | 81.15 | 217.5 | 13.7x | +12.3% | Global Institutional & Consumer
-------+----------------------------+-----------+--------------+-----------+---------+----------------------------------
[INFO] Query executed successfully. BNY relative outperformance vs peer median: +4.8% YTD.
TICKER | COMPANY NAME | PRICE ($) | MKT CAP ($B) | P/E (TTM) | 3M RET | PRIMARY SERVICE
-------+----------------------------+-----------+--------------+-----------+---------+----------------------------------
BNY | Bank of New York Mellon | 142.85 | 103.4 | 17.0x | -4.1% | Custody, Asset Servicing & Mgmt
STT | State Street Corp | 112.50 | 34.2 | 14.8x | -2.8% | Custody, Asset Servicing & ETFs
GS | Goldman Sachs Group | 895.32 | 260.7 | 13.6x | +3.2% | Investment Banking & Trading
MS | Morgan Stanley | 190.31 | 298.4 | 15.2x | +4.5% | Wealth Management & IB
JPM | JPMorgan Chase & Co. | 332.99 | 885.2 | 14.2x | +1.9% | Universal Banking & Commercial
WFC | Wells Fargo & Company | 74.80 | 252.7 | 12.0x | -1.5% | Consumer & Commercial Banking
C | Citigroup Inc. | 81.15 | 217.5 | 13.7x | +0.8% | Global Institutional & Consumer
-------+----------------------------+-----------+--------------+-----------+---------+----------------------------------
[INFO] Query executed successfully. Period covers July 13, 2026 – October 13, 2026. Custody peers experienced modest consolidation over Q3 following strong H1 gains.
@am
First off, this isn’t a ‘team’. Second, this company is run by a greasy British used car salesman who talks smooth. And a board that is only interested in shareprice so it can merge and sell later. Lastly, Wishing ill on this place is a personal choice. You don’t get to tell others how to think Robin wannabe. Only by failure, can things change for the better here. Here’s hoping the stock price goes to the bottom.
@at
No. Not entirely. And BNY is actually hitting steeper declines than the sector. Many other banks like JPMC , State street and Goldman have still shown growth. With analysts citing long term revenue growth concerns, known operational efficiency declines with concerns to use of non mature AI and more reductions, these are specific concerns to BNY. Not to mention AI backed stocks are actually showing significant growth. For such an AI based bank, this performance is not a good look. That’s why it is a hold. So, what in particular gives you reason to think it isnt BNY?
Do tell.
It is sector related. There is sector concern around bank earnings which are this week and the street is wary around impact of interest rates on NII and balance sheet interest rate risk management, as well as any potential changes to the various outlooks.
What in particular makes you think it isn’t sector movement?
The real insite (haha) will be the earnings call on Thursday.
This shouldn't be celebrated were all in the same BNY team. Celebrating the share price dropping isn't right guys.