Thread regarding Cisco Systems Inc. layoffs

H1B - Golden rules for hiring

The H1B visa program is designed to bring skilled workers to the U.S., but the hiring process for these workers needs to be streamlined for efficiency and integrity.

  1. Verify Authenticity of H1B Candidates: Companies should ensure that H1B candidates are legitimate and not submitting fake resumes. If a company hires an invalid H1B candidate, they should face a penalty 10-25 times the cost of the visa.
  2. Education Verification: All education credentials should be verified with official transcripts, signed and stamped by accredited universities.
  3. Work Experience Proof: Candidates should provide valid documentation of their work experience, including W-2 forms or tax records, to verify the number of years worked at previous companies.
  4. Reevaluate H1B Jobs: H1B positions should be reassessed for their specialized nature every 3 to 5 years, with a new Labor Condition Application (LCA) required for renewal.
  5. Green Card for Experienced Workers: Workers with 10 to 12 years of U.S. experience on an H1B visa, along with U.S. equivalent education, should automatically be eligible for a Green Card.
  6. I-140 and Green Card Eligibility: Workers with 5 or more years of experience in the U.S. should be automatically approved for an I-140 petition and eligible for a Green Card.
  7. U.S. Educated Students: U.S.-educated students should earn additional points towards their Green Card application to compensate for up to 5-7 years of work experience.
  8. Specialized Skills Only: Common technologies like Java, C, and C++ (unless they involve advanced, cutting-edge libraries) should not be considered specialized skills for H1B. Only truly new or emerging or on-demand technologies should qualify.
  9. Hiring Limit for Special Workers: Companies should be limited to hiring no more than 20-25% of their workforce on H1B visas to ensure U.S. workers are prioritized.
  10. Layoff Rules: In cases of mass layoffs, U.S. citizens should be retained over H1B workers, unless there are specific performance issues with the U.S. citizen.
  11. H1B Spouse Employment: H1B spouses should not automatically be allowed to work. If they wish to work, they should apply for their own H1B visa.
  12. Cancel Invalid H1B Renewals: Any H1B hires or renewals that don't meet the requirements for specialized education or experience should be canceled during their next renewal or stamping.
  13. U.S. Education Certification: A certificate from a U.S. university should be considered as an added qualification when evaluating foreign education.
  14. Relevant Education for the Role: Workers should have a relevant educational background for the role they’re hired for. For example, finance roles should require finance degrees, tech roles should require tech degrees, and management roles should require a management background.
  15. H1B Workers in Management: H1B visa holders should not be placed in managerial roles unless they have management education from a U.S. institution.
  16. Skill Upgrades for H1B Workers: H1B visa holders should have the opportunity to upgrade their skills, and once they complete U.S. degrees, they should be able to adjust their status to pursue a Green Card.
  17. Language Skills Testing: Like in countries such as Canada, the UK, and Australia, H1B applicants should be tested for English or Spanish proficiency to ensure effective communication in the workplace.
  18. Stricter L-Visa Regulations: L-visas should have stricter rules and regulations, similar to H1B, but can be more flexible for non-U.S. educated workers. However, L-visa holders should no longer be eligible for a Green Card. Can be granted for 3-7 years and no renewals after that.
by
| 2041 views | | 12 replies (last January 22, 2025) | Reply
Post ID: @OP+1jgrbybjv

12 replies (most recent on top)

@h2+1jgrbybjv

You actually think Elon Musk wants to get rid of H1Bs? That is hilarious.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2vs+1jgrbybjv

People don’t realize that hiring H1 is more expensive and uncertain. Apart from their salary, there’s additional cost to file visa and visa extension for the employee and their family, including filing fee, lawyer fee etc. and of these are expensive. Also, there’s an uncertainty around H1 extension, which can be rejected. The visa holder can be deported at port of entry for any reason, and cancel their visa, coz CBP officer has the power to do that.
So hiring an H1 is expensive and headache for the employer.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2ts+1jgrbybjv

The H1B visa program is designed to bring lower paid workers to the U.S and benefit large corporations by reducing their expenses and providing endentured servant employees who will work very long hours at lower pay and not be able to complain about it or job hop. Their skill level can be far worse than americans. It also allows chain migration for their families and reduces salaries and job availability to us workers as well. Same reason both democrats and republicans have allowed a wide open border. It provides a cheap labor pool they both profit from.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @wk+1jgrbybjv

Now that DOGE and Elon are running the show, expect H1Bs to double/triple from where they stand today.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @r7+1jgrbybjv

"Canada is ending SDS (student Direct stream) program."
Most countries enforce their borders and immigration rules, but not the US. Too many whiners and takers. Why allow the social fabric of what makes the United States great turned into the absolute TP stains that these people supposedly want to leave?

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @n0+1jgrbybjv

Report the Facts New Republic:

  1. Eliminate H1B Visas as # 1 Priority of DOGE
  2. Deport ALL H1B Visa Holders Immediately
  3. Hire American Citizens to Fill the Now Open H1B Billets
  4. Then Convene Tech Companies for Discussion on Reparations American Workers that had Their Futures Stolen
by
| | Reply
Post ID: @h2+1jgrbybjv

I’m for legal immigration just like many others. Uncontrolled immigration is bad. Why flood the country with low skilled workers when there are not enough jobs for the local population.

Canada is ending SDS (student Direct stream) program. Why? This is due to concerns about housing pressures and resource strains, impacting a large number of Indian applicants who previously benefited from the expedited process.

Australia capped students to 270k now.

Ireland has housing and accommodation crisis due to large number of international students.

Universities are after international students for huge profits and need to pay huge salaries for their staff and professors.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @gk+1jgrbybjv

One common issue in any company, including many big tech, is lack of good managers or leads with good mentorship. They do NOT know how to guide new/mid-level engineers to develop efficient and good software code. This is leading to bad engineers.

Majority on H1-B lack good communication or not able to explain things in clear and concise way. This is known fact.

Most of us know that H1-B is being abused now. Basic programming knowledge is being considered as rare technical skills these days. We can find many US undergraduate with those skills now.

It is a mad rush to escape their own country, come to USA and earn big dollars. But fire low and hire low environment is bad for everyone here in USA.

Big tech executives are all obsessed with profits and earnings. They don’t care about local USA jobs, outsource as much as possible and cut costs.

It is all about cost. Most of us fooled by super rich and politicians stating that capitalism is good. It is all about profits !

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @gh+1jgrbybjv

Sounds like Cisco shutdown and BO FA going on…

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @g0+1jgrbybjv
The truly sad thing is so few of you have worked at effective companies

THIS. My consistent gripe with my CISCO coworkers is that many of them have gone their entire careers being under/non-performers working at D-list companies...they cannot achieve results because they don't know what actual performance is.

Even in this market flooded with available talent, the rare rec at Cisco still seems to attract low quality talent...or even worse - people who have worked at Cisco before!

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @fn+1jgrbybjv

You talked of "Common technologies like Java, C, and C++" and yet Cisco has hired people into roles requiring skills in using at least one of these languages where candidates, local or H-1B, have absolutely zero experience, working on problems where again candidates don't have applicable experience. The work that is done at Cisco, both in the US and around the world, even when compared to the state of the art ages ago when these languages were still on the rise, is extremely poor. The truly sad thing is so few of you have worked at effective companies that you don't even understand how bad the work actually is.

Locally the US needs to fundamentally change its culture to value quality work and to get not only individuals but companies to get better across the board. If we spent more time doing the hard work of doing things better over time we'd be able to produce quite a bit more with fewer labor hours. The most simple example at Cisco is where a 10 line function with two bugs is copied 19 times in one branch then forked out to 1,000 branches. Now instead of two bugs you have 40,000. They taught basic refactoring in high school in the 1970s so why is Cisco systemically incapable of doing this?

The US does benefit from bringing in truly top talent, and given that many new companies are created by foreign born people we benefit by having them become citizens and grow more new jobs here. Being slave labor to low quality companies like Cisco then discarding them doesn't seem like the best option for anyone.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @fc+1jgrbybjv

During initial internet bo-m in the 90s, there was a genuine shortage of engineers. Majority of the jobs were new jobs, not replacement of US engineers or outsourcing.

May be around 25-30 thousand students were coming to USA from
India and China.

Now almost 100 thousand students are coming here annually from India and China has reduced little bit recently.
Almost 330K students from India and 270K students from China. They are all competing with USA citizens graduating from colleges/universities and grabbing a huge number of jobs in tech companies.

There is a lot of nepotism and influence used by these students to get into tech companies.

Many of the hiring and candidate selection is totally biased and preference is given to these international students when there are few thousands of us citizens with engineering degrees.

Many senior engineers are getting replaced by international outsourcing companies. Majority of H1-B engineers are protected during layoff and reduction in force.

Time to change this forever with new rules. Control the flow of international students, many won’t find jobs due to intense competition for few jobs.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @ec+1jgrbybjv

Post a reply

: