At the end of the day, The Judge believed that CHK’s problems were primarily caused by the temporary drop in prices due to Covid-19.
In Judge Jones mind, 25 years of loading up the balance sheet with expensive debt to drill non-economic wells, while the CHK executives lived like Robber Barons and told extravagant lies to their investors, had nothing to do with CHK’s problems.
I don’t think the UCC lawyers anticipated or prepared for the Judge being that incompetent/gullible.
The UCC got out lawyered by Kirkland lawyers that were quite bad themselves.
That these lawyers convinced anybody that they should get much over minimum wage, let alone hourly rates exceeding $1,000, is pretty cool.
Now, I’ve got hope for some of my no-account relatives. If the Kirkland and Brown, Rudnick folks can steal that kind of money, anyone should be able to do it if they actually try.