Thread regarding State Farm Insurance layoffs

Marketing leadership is full of herself

In the recent Marketing dept meeting, she named 4 things that the State Farm brand has going for it: the like a good neighbor tagline, the jingle, the color red, and Jake.

Not one single mention of the agent. Yet the agent is our strength and differentiator. Without the agent, State Farm is no different than any other insurance company. By removing the agent and highlighting Jake, it only reinforces the idea that insurance is a commodity. Agents sell our products. Not Jake.

Dear Tipsord: Do you really want someone in Marketing leadership who prioritizes her own ego and Jake creation over the agent? Do you want someone in Marketing leadership who doesn’t value or even acknowledge the agent as a strength or differentiator? Who was it that decided to stop using Like a Good Neighbor? It certainly wasn’t anyone at the analyst level.

We strongly suggest you fire that fat dead weight at the top and also get a new agency of record or else buckle up and get ready for the bumpy ride when we fall to #2 to commemorate our 100 yr anniversary.

by
| 3591 views | | 23 replies (last March 4, 2020) | Reply
Post ID: @OP+13zAO41K

23 replies (most recent on top)

They’ll just ignore those YouTube comments with valid criticisms of their lazy and tone deaf effort to resurrect that dinosaur of a commercial. It’s what they do best in “leadership”.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @fzhl+13zAO41K

If you want HONEST feedback, head on over to YouTube and read the comments on the new Jake commercial. Not good.

https://youtu.be/tEaTrmlZUgw

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @fdug+13zAO41K

People dont care about Brands - they want quality service to be delivered for a fair price with customer service.

Then you can promote your family to higher places and dont care about your employees.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @eugu+13zAO41K

The real world: "They ever ask you what your wearing?" Yes! "I'm wearing shorts, flip flops, Hawaiian short sleeve shirt, nose and eye piercings, tattoos on my neck, arms and legs...you got a problem with that?"

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @dmat+13zAO41K

Artificial intelligence and rules based systems are just that. Fake and Artificial.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @3utx+13zAO41K

Everybody at home thinking my job is safe is already obsolete.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @3hvy+13zAO41K

Tipsturd and stooges have no idea how to fix the problems they caused. It's literally guess work. Agents are out too. It's coming. Secretly developing trained spider monkeys to do agents jobs but monkeys were much smarter so program sc-apped.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @3onj+13zAO41K

Marketing is clueless. They just announced they will be discontinuing the Community Offers Program. We all knew in the rank and file that it would fail. What a waste of time, money, and embarrassment.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2bog+13zAO41K

1qzd Yeah we need to lose some Corporate Fat and its not the agents or the adjusters its The 100 VP’s walking around like they are busy and doing absolutely nothing. What a total waste Sears had the same corporate Fat look how the ended up. Time to Trim Executive Level its like nobody cares anymore.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2voe+13zAO41K

We are #3 in Florida already, the last three years have been a total nightmare, most of the new agents either cheat the system or starve. Who ever is doing the underwriting modeling and marketing needs to leave immediately. It’s so bad most agents have set-up other businesses. Sad day for the Farm never thought I would see such a screw up in my career. I hope everyone has been putting money away this doesn’t seem to be getting any better, even after listening to The VP’s and SL’s they are just hanging on for the Pension. And total waste of premium not sure exactly what they do other than send endless emails.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @2jqv+13zAO41K

Wake up... State Farm is going to be #2 by 2022 and no brand changes are going to help. Marketing Leadership doesn’t care about anyone but themselves. They would rather die on the sword than be human and listen to the employees. The work environment is terrible, loud... a call center! The new Jake would not represent SF knowing how the marketing employees r being treated.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1cmk+13zAO41K

We’re do you think the money comes from to fund our investments. The investment side is to offset our overall insurance pricing that’s why we are a mutual company. If our plan is to price our products on just current year results we are going to lose big time

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1ozu+13zAO41K

They say that “this time it’s data driven.” What have they been doing until now? If the data shows us it’s not working, get rid of them.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1woy+13zAO41K

@1qmf They treat us just like the "Jake" you describe. We're all treated like robot androids and expected to act accordingly, because we're just widgets in a factory.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1jwk+13zAO41K

Marketing really missed the mark with the new Jake campaign. And that’s coming from a black guy. 20 year agent here.

My daughter and her friends are of a generation who pride themselves on what makes them unique and different in a sea of sameness. Her generation is the next generation of customers we have to win with if we want to stay #1, but marketing is making it impossible.

This new campaign is sending the message that we are all named Jake, we are all generic, we can all be swapped out at any time, we all dress like Target employees and there’s nothing special about us.

This is the exact opposite message we should be sending if we want to appeal to a customer who celebrates their individuality.

I’m not the only agent who dislikes Jake and is offended that marketing removed us agents from our advertising.

Wake up marketing!

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1qmf+13zAO41K

the billions banked come from our investments, not our insurance business

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1une+13zAO41K

Well they certainly not willing to pay for our claims service and definitely not our underwriting modeling they are leaving in droves.
And we are banking Billions something is not adding up

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1nmh+13zAO41K

We will have agents as long as customers want them and are willing to pay for them. That simple.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @1bsa+13zAO41K

Insurance already is a commodity. It is mandated by state legislatures. It is regulated by the states. What's the primary difference between state farm and geico's policies? Very little in terms of coverage due to state regulation.

It comes down to price and claim service.

with the introduction of the internet, it is easier to shop for different companies than ever before. brand loyalty is now a thing of the past. those companies who are able to play in the interenet world will be those companies that survive and thrive. why do you think geico is about to catch and pass state farm?

state farm mgt is acting like sear's mgt and look where sears is today. now, look where geico is today.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @irr+13zAO41K

Those 4 things are not cool

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @wwm+13zAO41K

Tipsord has no plans of getting rid of the agents. Customers don’t come to State Farm because it’s cheaper, customers come to State Farm because of the agents. Marketing leadership is so disconnected and ego driven that they’re prioritizing their own “creative” over the brand strength of the agents and State Farm’s business model. Like the OP said, Jake is only reinforcing commoditization, a concept where the lowest priced competitor in the market wins, and it won’t be State Farm.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @rfp+13zAO41K

Talking to a friend the other day who has been insured with a competitor for 30 years. He said, "do you think I should shop around for insurance?" I asked a few questions. Do they treat you well? Do you have a good relationship with your agent? Can you go into his office and feel welcome anytime? Is he/she responsive to your phone calls, etc? Have your claims been handled effeciently and fairly without any hassle? His answers were resoundingly yes! You can guess what my response was.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @pbw+13zAO41K

We’re have you been, the plan has always been to go direct why do you think marketing is pushing Jake?
It’s already a bumpy ride, #2 try 3 or 4 in most states we are already there.
Wait until the profit is announced from last year.

by
| | Reply
Post ID: @uyt+13zAO41K

Post a reply

: